Skip to content
Christmas deliveryChristmas deliveryOrder by Monday 21 December for UK delivery

Cart

Article: Alpaca vs Cashmere Scarves: Which Is Warmer and Softer?

Woman wearing a grey plaid alpaca scarf
alpaca

Alpaca vs Cashmere Scarves: Which Is Warmer and Softer?

Alpaca and cashmere are two of the softest natural fibres you can wear around your neck, and both make a scarf that feels far nicer than everyday wool. They are not the same, though. Alpaca is generally the warmer and harder-wearing of the two; cashmere is lighter and has a softer, more delicate handle. Which is better depends on how you'll wear it and what you value most.

This guide compares the two fibres, explains what to look for in a good scarf, and suggests alpaca and cashmere pieces for yourself or as a gift.

Alpaca vs cashmere at a glance

Alpaca Cashmere
Where it comes from The fleece of the alpaca, mostly raised in the Andes of South America The fine undercoat of cashmere goats
Warmth Very warm for its weight; often described as warmer than sheep's wool Warm and very light
Feel Soft and smooth, with a slight sheen; baby alpaca is the finest grade Exceptionally soft, with a fine, velvety handle
Durability Strong fibre that tends to wear well More delicate; may pill at first, especially where it rubs
Lanolin Contains no lanolin, which some people who react to sheep's wool find easier to wear Very little lanolin once processed
Best for Cold, windy days and everyday wear Light warmth, layering and close to the face

Which is warmer?

For most people, alpaca. Alpaca fibre is known for trapping warm air efficiently, so an alpaca scarf feels noticeably cosy on cold, windy days without being heavy. Cashmere is also warm, but its strength is warmth with very little weight, which makes it ideal close to the skin or under a coat collar.

If you're out walking, commuting or standing on a cold platform, an alpaca scarf is the safer choice. If you want something light you can keep on indoors, choose cashmere.

Which is softer?

Both are very soft, but they feel different. Cashmere has a famously fine, velvety touch. Alpaca, especially baby alpaca (the finest grade, not fibre from young animals), is smooth and silky with a subtle sheen. Many people find good baby alpaca as soft as cashmere; others prefer cashmere's lighter, fluffier feel. If you can, touch both.

Which lasts longer?

Alpaca is generally the harder-wearing fibre and tends to resist pilling well. Cashmere is more delicate: some light pilling in the first few wears is normal and can be removed gently with a cashmere comb. Either will last for years if you store it clean, folded rather than hung, and away from moths.

How to choose a good scarf

  • Check the fibre: look for the percentage of alpaca or cashmere on the label, and where it was made.
  • Think about weight: a brushed or woven scarf is warmer; a fine knit is lighter and drapes more easily.
  • Size and shape: a long scarf can be wrapped twice; a neckwarmer (snood) stays put without knotting and is ideal for active days.
  • Colour: undyed natural shades go with every coat; a reversible scarf gives you two colours in one.

Our alpaca and cashmere pieces

Alpaca Plaid Scarf

Undyed plaid alpaca scarf with twisted fringes, made in Peru

Made in Peru from undyed alpaca in natural shades, with a soft brushed texture, a subtle plaid and twisted fringes. Warm but light, and easy to wear with any coat. Shop the Alpaca Plaid Scarf in grey, white, natural or brown.

Two Tone Baby Alpaca Scarf

Reversible two-tone baby alpaca scarf in pink and lilac

Made in Peru from fine baby alpaca, and reversible, with a different shade on each side and frayed edges. Shop the Two Tone Baby Alpaca Scarf.

Scottish Cashmere Neckwarmer

Burgundy Scottish cashmere neckwarmer

100% Scottish cashmere, made in Scotland. Wear it as a neckwarmer or pull it up as a hood; it's light enough to keep on indoors and stays in place on walks or the slopes. Shop the Scottish Cashmere Neckwarmer.

To complete the look

See all women's scarves and hats and gloves.

Alpaca and cashmere gifts for women

Plaid alpaca scarf and alpaca wristwarmers worn together, from The Alpaca Scarf & Wristwarmer Gift

A good scarf is one of the easiest gifts to get right: no sizing, and it gets worn every day all winter.

For more ideas, see our Christmas gifts for women and Christmas gifts for Mum.

Caring for alpaca and cashmere

  • Hand wash in cool water with a gentle wool or cashmere wash, or dry clean. Check the care label on each piece.
  • Don't wring or tumble dry. Press out water in a towel and lay flat to dry.
  • Store clean and folded, ideally in a breathable bag, to protect from moths. Lavender helps keep drawers fresh; see our lavender bags.

Frequently asked questions

Is alpaca warmer than cashmere?

Generally, yes. Alpaca is known for very good insulation for its weight, so an alpaca scarf usually feels warmer on cold, windy days. Cashmere is warm too, but is valued most for being light.

Is alpaca softer than cashmere?

Cashmere is usually considered the softer fibre, but baby alpaca comes very close, and some people prefer its smoother, silkier feel.

Is alpaca itchy?

Good-quality alpaca, especially baby alpaca, is not usually itchy. It contains no lanolin, which some people who react to sheep's wool find easier to wear. If you have very sensitive skin, try it against your wrist first.

What is baby alpaca?

Baby alpaca is a grade of fibre, not wool from young animals. It refers to the finest, softest fibre, usually taken from the animal's back and sides.

Which makes a better gift?

For someone who walks, commutes or feels the cold, an alpaca scarf. For someone who wants something light and refined to wear every day, cashmere. If in doubt, a neckwarmer is an easy, no-sizing choice.

Final thoughts

Choose alpaca for warmth and durability, and cashmere for featherlight softness. Either is a scarf you'll reach for every winter, and both make a gift that gets used.

Shop women's scarves · Shop Christmas gifts

More from the blog

Isobel Ridley, founder of Lavender Hill Clothing

Female-Founded British Clothing Brands to Know in 2026

Some of Britain's most distinctive fashion businesses were started by women who saw something missing from the market and built it themselves. From everyday…

Read more

Independent British Clothing Brands Worth Knowing in 2026

If you want clothing with more individuality than the high street, Britain has a good range of independent fashion brands. They often offer a clear point of view…

Read more
Women's olive and white striped long sleeve linen T-shirt

British Slow Fashion Brands: A Guide to Buying Better in 2026

Buying clothes more thoughtfully does not mean giving up fashion, building a perfectly minimalist wardrobe or never buying anything new. At its simplest, slow…

Read more